All’s Fair, One of the Worst Shows on TV, Renewed

1 day ago7 min read7 comments

In a move that has left critics and audiences alike scratching their heads, Hulu has officially renewed 'All’s Fair,' the Ryan Murphy-produced legal dramedy widely panned as one of the worst shows on television, for a second season. This decision feels like a plot twist ripped straight from a particularly chaotic episode of reality TV, defying all conventional wisdom that suggests a series starring Kim Kardashian, Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, and Glenn Close should either be a prestige powerhouse or a spectacular flop, not this baffling middle ground that somehow earns another chance.The show’s initial reception was a masterclass in social media dragging, with viewers and professional critics uniting in a rare moment of consensus to roast its tonal inconsistencies, underbaked legal plots, and the perplexing underutilization of its Oscar-nominated talent like Glenn Close, who deserved far more than the legal-lite material she was given. It’s the kind of renewal that makes you question the streaming algorithm overlords—was it sheer morbid curiosity that drove viewing hours, or is there a secret cult following we don't know about, binge-watching it ironically with popcorn and memes? Ryan Murphy, the maestro of televised maximalism behind 'Glee' and 'American Horror Story,' has built an empire on knowing exactly what audiences want, often before they know it themselves, but 'All’s Fair' represents a rare miscalculation, a show that feels like it was focus-grouped into oblivion, lacking the sharp, defining edge of his greatest hits.The casting of Kim Kardashian, following her surprisingly effective dramatic turn in 'American Horror Story: Delicate,' was a headline-generating gamble that, in this context, failed to pay off, as her performance here was lost in a sea of legal clichés and underwritten character arcs that even her significant star power couldn't elevate. Meanwhile, powerhouse actors like Niecy Nash-Betts, fresh off her Emmy win, and Naomi Watts were seemingly stranded in parallel storylines that never quite converged into a compelling whole, leaving fans to wonder what could have been if the script had matched the cast's caliber.This renewal speaks volumes about the new metrics of success in the streaming era, where completion rates and social media buzz—even if it's overwhelmingly negative—can sometimes outweigh critical disdain, suggesting that Hulu sees a value in the show that extends beyond traditional quality markers, perhaps as a conversation starter or a so-bad-it's-good asset in a crowded content landscape. The precedent for such a turnaround is slim but not nonexistent; shows like 'Riverdale' and 'Emily in Paris' weathered initial critical storms to become cultural touchstones through sheer audacity and a dedicated fanbase, but 'All’s Fair' will need a significant creative overhaul in its second season to achieve that status, potentially requiring Ryan Murphy to personally step in and re-inject the campy, high-stakes drama that defines his best work. For now, the renewal stands as one of the most perplexing entertainment headlines of the year, a testament to the unpredictable, often illogical, nature of the television industry where not all that glitters is gold, but sometimes, it gets a second season anyway.

#featured

#All's Fair

#Hulu

#Ryan Murphy

#Kim Kardashian

#negative reviews

#season 2

Stay Informed. Act Smarter.

Get weekly highlights, major headlines, and expert insights — then put your knowledge to work in our live prediction markets.