Want someone to change? Psychology says nagging doesn't work.

2 hours ago7 min read

For fifteen years of marriage, I've engaged in a quiet domestic war over a simple ball of laundry. My husband, an otherwise considerate man, consistently leaves his socks and underwear on the bathroom floor after showering, and my response has been a relentless, fruitless campaign of nagging.This pattern, a familiar soundtrack in countless homes, feels intuitively correct—if someone forgets, you remind them, right? Yet psychology reveals a profound truth we often ignore in our frustration: nagging is perhaps the least effective tool for inspiring genuine change. It operates on a flawed premise, as psychologist Scott Wetzler explains, born from a perception that we won't get what we want unless we persistently ask.The result isn't compliance but a deep-seated resentment, a feeling of being demeaned that causes the other person to psychologically withhold the very behavior we're demanding. This dynamic, corrosive enough to erode relationship satisfaction between partners, proves equally destructive in the trenches of parenting or the collaborative spaces of the workplace, where constant reminders become a grating noise that stifles motivation rather than fostering it.The alternative, as emerging research suggests, requires a counterintuitive jujitsu of the heart. A recent University of Toronto study led by psychologist Natalie Sisson, published in the *Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin*, meticulously tracked couples and discovered a powerful catalyst for change: gratitude.When individuals felt their efforts, however nascent, were acknowledged and appreciated by their partners, they developed an internal drive to continue improving. Over nine months, those who felt most seen and thanked made the most significant behavioral shifts.This isn't merely about being polite; it's about understanding the fundamental mechanics of human motivation. Positive reinforcement, a principle we readily accept in training animals, is often the first thing we abandon in our complex human relationships.My own instinct, upon spotting a lone sock finally in the hamper, isn't to offer praise but to mentally catalogue the hundreds of times I’ve done the task myself. Yet, venting that frustration only reinforces the negative cycle.Beyond gratitude, other experts offer complementary strategies. BJ Fogg of Stanford’s Persuasive Technology Lab suggests riding the 'motivational wave'—stepping in with concrete support when the other person shows a flicker of interest in changing, like touring gyms together after they mention wanting to get fit.Psychologist Devon Price advises a diagnostic approach, digging for the hidden barriers—is it a time crunch, a fear of failure, a lack of skill?—that block the path to change. And time-use expert Laura Vanderkam recommends leading with vulnerability, discussing your own self-improvement journeys to open a non-confrontational dialogue about challenges and trade-offs.What unites these approaches is their foundation in empathy and support, a stark contrast to the adversarial stance of nagging. The choice, then, is between the short-term satisfaction of complaint and the long-term efficacy of connection. It’s a lesson woven into the fabric of our daily interactions, reminding us that to help someone change, we must first change how we ask.

#behavior change

#psychology

#relationships

#gratitude

#positive reinforcement

#featured

Stay Informed. Act Smarter.

Get weekly highlights, major headlines, and expert insights — then put your knowledge to work in our live prediction markets.