Three 20th Century Pop Artists Who Missed Mainstream Fame

2 hours ago7 min read2 comments

The ruthless machinery of mainstream pop music has always chewed up and spit out artists of sublime talent, leaving behind a graveyard of almost-superstars whose names echo only in the collections of dedicated crate-diggers and music bloggers. While the 20th century gave us icons whose faces are etched into the cultural firmament, it’s the haunting melodies of those who nearly made it that often provide the most compelling B-sides to music history.Take the case of Judee Sill, a figure whose life was a tempest of trauma and transcendent talent. Emerging from a background that included armed robbery and heroin addiction, she channeled her struggles into a unique brand of country-tinged baroque pop on her 1971 self-titled debut, an album produced by the legendary David Geffen.With a voice that could shift from a fragile whisper to a soaring, gospel-inflected cry and songwriting that wove complex classical influences with cosmic American themes, she was poised for the Laurel Canyon pantheon. Her song ‘Jesus Was a Cross Maker’ was a work of devastating beauty, yet her career was sabotaged by her own mercurial nature and the industry’s inability to categorize her singular vision.After a second album, 1973’s ‘Heart Food’—now considered a lost masterpiece—failed to connect with a mass audience, she retreated from music, her life ending in obscurity in 1979. Her story is a stark lesson in how the music business, for all its glamour, often lacks the patience for artists who defy easy packaging.Then there is the enigmatic case of Arthur Russell, a cellist and composer who floated between the avant-garde classical scene of New York’s The Kitchen and the pulsating dance floors of the Paradise Garage. Russell was a man of contradictions, a Buddhist from Iowa who created some of the most disarmingly beautiful disco records ever pressed, like ‘Is It All Over My Face?’ under the moniker Loose Joints.His work was a fluid, genre-less exploration; he would record a haunting folk song with just his voice and cello one day and a sprawling, 40-minute electronic composition the next. His masterpiece, the posthumously compiled ‘World of Echo’, is a testament to his unique genius, a collection of songs that feel both intimate and infinite.Yet, during his lifetime, he was plagued by perfectionism, leaving behind hundreds of reels of unfinished tapes and a legacy known only to a cult following. His commercial breakthrough was perpetually ‘just around the corner,’ thwarted by his unwillingness to compromise and an industry that demanded a coherent product.His eventual death from AIDS in 1992 silenced one of pop’s most quietly revolutionary voices. Across the Atlantic, the story of Vashti Bunyan offers a different kind of near-miss, one defined not by chaotic energy but by a quiet, deliberate retreat.In 1970, after a failed attempt at a pop career, she embarked on a horse-drawn wagon journey from London to the Outer Hebrides, an odyssey that inspired her album ‘Just Another Diamond Day’. The record is a whisper of folk-tinged serenity, a perfect, crystalline artifact of the fading hippie dream.Yet, upon its release, it was met with commercial indifference, leading a heartbroken Bunyan to abandon music entirely for three decades, believing her work had been lost to time. The album’s rediscovery in the early 2000s, its reissue catapulting it to cult status, is a testament to its enduring power, proving that sometimes an artist’s impact is not measured in chart positions but in the slow, persistent bloom of their influence over generations.These three artists—Sill, Russell, and Bunyan—form a holy trinity of what-might-have-been. Their careers are case studies in the fragile alchemy of fame, where raw talent is only one variable in an equation that includes timing, temperament, and the capricious tastes of the public. They remind us that the pop canon is not a definitive record of quality, but a curated collection shaped by commerce and chance, and that some of the most profound music ever created exists in the shadows, waiting for the world to finally catch up.

#featured

#music history

#pop music

#underrated artists

#20th century

#Vice

#editorial picks news