Why the beloved Maui Invitational faces an uncertain future

7 hours ago7 min read2 comments

When the founders of this new Thanksgiving week college basketball tournament first slid into Kelvin Sampson’s DMs a few years back, the Houston coach thought they were selling him a bridge in Brooklyn. The pitch was wild: a guaranteed million bucks in NIL money for his players, just for showing up.“Man, get out of here,” Sampson remembers thinking, the skepticism dripping off every word. “Ain’t nobody going to believe that.” But then came the Zoom calls—the co-founders, the private equity suits, the whole crew—and the picture started to clear. They had corporate sponsors locked in, the NCAA had given a cautious nod, and the money was real.For a coach like Sampson, navigating the wild west of the transfer portal where the highest bidder often wins, this wasn’t just an invitation; it was a life raft. “Right now, the schools with the most money get the best [players], especially in the portal,” he laid bare last Friday.“You can be the greatest recruiter ever. If you ain’t got enough money, you ain’t going to get your guy.Simple as that. ” And just like that, the tectonic plates of college basketball’s early season shifted.The Players Era Festival, with its Las Vegas glitz and cold, hard cash, has rapidly become the new king of the hill, leaving legacy tournaments like the iconic Maui Invitational scrambling in its wake. Remember that feeling of tuning into Maui, that jam-packed high-school gym in Lahaina with the best teams in the country going toe-to-toe? That magic is now under direct threat.The proof is in the pudding, or in this case, the payouts. After the inaugural Players Era event last November actually delivered the cash as promised, top-tier programs flocked to this year’s sophomore edition like it was a Black Friday sale.This year’s 18-team field is a murderer's row: Houston, Michigan, Alabama, Gonzaga, with Iowa State, St. John’s, Tennessee, and Auburn right behind.Twelve are getting AP Top 25 votes. Ten have been to a Final Four in the last decade.It’s a concentration of talent that makes other tournaments look like the JV squad. Meanwhile, the 42nd edition of the Maui Invitational that tipped off this week is a ghost of its former self.Only NC State is ranked. Only Texas danced in last year’s NCAA tournament.They’re joined by a crew of Arizona State, Boise State, Seton Hall, USC, Washington State, and host Chaminade. It’s a stark contrast, and it’s not by accident.Eighteen months ago, Maui unveiled a 2025 field with Baylor, Oregon, and UNLV. All three got a better offer from the Players Era and bounced, leaving Maui organizers frantically dialing for replacements.The same story unfolded for the Battle 4 Atlantis, which saw Auburn and Ohio State pull out, leaving behind what might be the weakest field in its 14-year history. The message from the market is deafening: in the NIL era, prestige and a nice vacation aren't enough.You gotta pay to play. Kansas coach Bill Self, always measured, put it carefully: “That’s up to the organizers and the event and the promoters to see if they can do whatever the Players Era is doing.So I don’t think they’re in danger unless maybe they don’t make some adjustments. ” Translation: Show me the money.Why would Kansas pay its own way to Maui when someone in Vegas is willing to cut them a check? This isn't just about scheduling; it's an existential crisis for the sport's traditions. The Maui Invitational is college basketball comfort food.It’s Adam Morrison pouring in 43 points in that epic triple-overtime war against Michigan State in 2005. It’s Ball State taking down No.4 Kansas and No. 3 UCLA on back-to-back days in 2001.It’s the 2023 field that boasted five of the preseason top 11. These are the moments that build the narrative of a season, played in a unique, intimate cauldron that half-empty NBA arenas in Vegas can't replicate.And let's talk about that Vegas setup for a second. The Players Era’s format this year is, frankly, a mess.There’s no clear bracket. Eighteen teams are split into two pods playing in two different arenas.The “championship” is decided by a baffling set of tiebreakers: margin of victory, total points scored, points allowed, and even the AP poll. It feels less like a cohesive tournament and more like a loosely organized three-day scrimmage for TV contracts, prioritizing the financial transaction over the competitive purity that makes events like Maui so special.But for coaches like Sampson, the soul of the game is a secondary concern when the financial stability of their program is on the line. He was so convinced that when the Big 12 came calling, he became its biggest evangelist.“You guys are crazy if you don’t do it,” he told his peers. This week, that faith was rewarded spectacularly when the Big 12 announced a multi-year, $50 million equity partnership with the Players Era, guaranteeing eight of its teams a spot starting in 2026.“We’re going to do this every year it’s available,” Sampson declared, citing “donor fatigue” and the need for self-sufficiency. The game has changed, irrevocably.The Players Era Festival might not have Maui’s charm yet, but it has its finger firmly on the pulse of modern college athletics. The question now is whether the old guards can find a way to match its financial firepower, or if the cherished memories of Lahaina will become just that—memories.

#featured

#college basketball

#Maui Invitational

#Players Era Festival

#NIL money

#tournament disruption

#recruiting

#Houston Cougars

#Bill Self